Kusuriya no Hitorigoto – Episode 48 Review (END)

「はじまり」 (Hajimari)
“The Beginning”

While the finale was entertaining in some respects, it also stepped on all the land mines I expected it to and hoped it wouldn’t.

For starters, there are the children. As hinted, the children were rescued with the resurrection potion. Of course, the plan doesn’t escape Jinshi’s sharp gaze, but he looks the other way in honor of his promise to Loulan. On the one hand, I’m glad the children were saved- it would have been terribly tragic if they were executed. I had become especially fond of Kyou-u (now Chou-u), so it was a relief to have him back in the picture. However, it’s almost laughably unrealistic. Like, they went about it in the grandest, most unbelievable way. That Jinshi would be in the same room while it was happening, latch on to the plan, then pretend he saw nothing. Oh, and he even lends a hand. All while being the king’s brother and head of the Forbidden Army? Ummmm…..I don’t think so. His humanity for sure would incline him to stay his hand, but his position sure would not. Survivors, no matter how young, present the possibility of a future rebellion, if not an overthrow. If it couldn’t get more ridiculous, Ah Duo- the former consort- adopts most of the children and Suirei. I suppose that way the royal family could easily monitor them, but you’d think her being shrewd royalty, she’d have objections- especially considering the attempts Suirei made on the royal family’s lives. It all smells horrendously like a rosy, fantastical happy ending- the kind that make me groan.

I did find it interesting how the resurrection potion affected the children differently. Chou-u lost all his memories and is partially paralyzed. As I surmised much earlier, he ends up in the pleasure district, though under Mao Mao’s tutelage, not Luomen’s. As Mao Mao muses, perhaps it’s for the best that he has amnesia- I don’t know how he would bear up under the weight of knowing what happened. The same could be said for the other children, who did not lose their memories and have to live with it.

I was surprised that Mao Mao was released from her palace duties. She was well liked by Gyokuyou and Jinshi couldn’t bear to be away from her, not to mention that Lakan would have something to say about his daughter being sent back to the pleasure district. It does make sense that they’d want to keep Luomen- he’s got the skills, and he finally gets his reputation restored. Perhaps, too, Jinshi recognizes the danger of having Mao Mao around him, given his title that she now knows, and his inability to control himself around her.

Speaking of… Jinshi visits Mao Mao and becomes hilariously at a loss for words when he realizes the long awaited conversation is no longer needed because, well, Mao Mao has finally caught up to reality. I did appreciate Mao Mao’s insistence that a scar shouldn’t undermine her value- the whole thing about women needing to protect their face more than men is rather sexist. In fact, the scar seems to be a turn on for Mao Mao, the way she keeps stroking and gazing at it (even if it is the suture skills that fascinate her more than the man wearing it). She also made an interesting (and truthful) observation that Jinshi’s beauty blinded people to the man beneath it. It shows that she sees his true worth- which is kind of romantic, even if she didn’t mean it that way. Jinshi, being Jinshi, gets handsy- or should I say, bitey. Mao Mao is rather blasé about his advances, other than commenting on saliva and poison. Whether that means she’s just resigned herself, is open to it, or stunned, I can’t say. Jinshi for sure needs to keep his hands and teeth to himself though- especially in somber situations where you have “dead” children in the room right after a big battle.

One of the (many) major developments this season has been Mao Mao opening her heart and learning emotions. We see this come to a head here when one of Gyokuyou’s maids drops off letters from Xiaolan for Mao Mao and Shisui. Xiaolan knows nothing- the cover story being that Mao Mao and Shisui were hired elsewhere. She’s preparing to start a new job through palace connections, but still wanted to say good bye. While reading the letters, Mao Mao starts crying– I think the first time we’ve seen her cry, ever. That got me a little emotional too. She’s come a long way from begrudgingly allowing Xiaolan and Shisui to tag along, to considering her a friend and missing her, to the point of tears. This slow development over two seasons has actually been one of my favorite parts.

I was not really a fan of how it ended- Shisui (now Tamamo, though the “jade” connection still runs strong) apparently survived, the hair stick apparently took the bullet for her. It seems she’s headed for “the other side of the ocean”, which could mean Korea, Taiwan, or Japan, depending on where in China she is. It’s too much of a “wrapped with a neat bow” kind of ending for my tastes.

Now that the finale has ended, how does season as a whole sum up? I enjoyed this season more than the first one (not that the first one was bad or anything). There were a few dud episodes like the bathhouse one or the ghost story one. But other than that- the plot was engaging, I felt like each week left me wanting more- I found the political intrigue with the rebellion and intertwining of various story strands with Jinshi’s identity, the previous emperor, and so on, entertaining. The character development was also well done- particularly with Mao Mao and Jinshi. It is a shame it ended on such a light, run of the mill ending with a happy ever after for everyone, but overall, the series gave me enough to eagerly want a third season. Which I suppose will come eventually, though I’ve heard that it’ll take a while for the source material to get to the point where another season is possible. I am grateful for the season it’s been and that it left me generally satisfied, even with a disappointing finale. Which says something about the quality, as sometimes a meh ending can unfavorably tint everything that came before it.

5 Comments

  1. Angelus

    There’s no shortage at all of LN source material, enough for another 6 seasons at the rate it’s being adapted.

    Would Jinshi really have let the children live? Of course he would, he made a promise to Loulan – the bigger the man, the bigger the promise, which is why he can’t break it. As for Loulan’s fate, who knows whether we’ll see her again or not, I certainly don’t because I’m way behind with the LNs at the moment.

    And handsy Jinshi will raise all sorts of eyebrows in various places, but from his point of view, everything he sees is his so he’s simply not used to doing things that we mere mortals have to, like asking permission before doing something. Maomao has fascinated him from the moment he first met her, partly I think because he just can’t understand her. And she doesn’t understand things either, like why her examination of his sutures is mistaken for a gesture of affection. Anyway, their relationship is the emotional core of the whole story so it’s not going anywhere much in either direction for a while yet.

  2. Dromoka

    I think thay choose the “Happy Ending” route becasue at the time this episode was made they did not really know if there will be a third season, and this ending is good enough for a series ending.
    It’s still a lot of LN material, but other popular LN animes do not get new seasons even if they have enough material *cough* No Game No Life *gough*

    • Angelus

      It ended exactly the same way as volume 4 of the LN ended, so I don’t think there was anything to read into that decision. But given how the series has been doing generally, including on Japanese TV, where it easily beat long-running shows such as One Piece and Doraemon, another season was never in real doubt, the only question was when.

      The NGNL situation is much more complex. Yes, it was very popular, but first there were the plagiarism allegations against the author and then the general realization that some people were grossed out by various aspects of Sora and Shiro’s relationship, not to mention the sexually abusive way they treat Steph. Then on top of that, Amazon pulled a lot of the LNs in various countries without explanation, although the illustrations were widely blamed. Even the author apparently says that money was never an issue but he still has no real idea why a second series was never made, other than maybe the first series was just so good that another one would be a letdown. Which is a great shame, as far as I’m concerned.

  3. trunksca

    The ending makes no sense to me. There is no way Suirei should not have been executed by their laws. She was sneaking in and out of the rear palace basically putting the emperors family in danger. The kids I can understand. Mao Mao leaving the real palace I cannot. It has been proved over and over to be extremely useful and knowledgable. Th emperor himself would have requested her stay. The new empress would have kept her services. And didn’t Shinji purchased her services from her grandma anyway? I am a bit annoyed by this ending.

    • Angelus

      Suirei was spared mainly because she has imperial blood and Ah-Duo taking her in probably also swung the balance in her favor. And she’ll have to spend the rest of her days being closely watched and effectively under house arrest rather than being free.

      As for Maomao, it couldn’t be admitted that there was a secret tunnel so the cover story for her disappearance from the palace was that she’d been dismissed from service. Yes, Jinshi effectively owns her, but you can’t be seen to dismiss someone and then immediately hire them again. There are many more LN volumes so it’s probably no spoiler to say that she’ll be back soon enough.

Comments are closed